The Scottish National Party has failed to take all of Scotland’s largest cities after Labor gained control of Edinburgh with the help of Liberal Democrats and Conservatives.
The SNP hoped to retain power in the Scottish capital after winning a majority of seats and negotiating a coalition deal with the Scottish Greens that left them three seats for general control.
However, to the outrage of the SNP leadership, the Greens and some left-wing critics, Labor took over as the city’s minority administration after giving the Liberal Democrats and Conservatives the task of convening and attached to key committees. As a sign of internal unease over the agreement, two Labor councilors abstained.
Labor insisted that these charges did not reach a coalition, which had been largely ruled out by its Scottish leader Anas Sarwar before the council election three weeks ago, as they held non-partisan political and regulatory positions on licenses and planning.
SNP Deputy Prime Minister John Swinney, who replaces Nicola Sturgeon while not working with Covid, accused Sarwar of hypocrisy during questions from the Prime Minister. He said Labor was now in bed with the “toxic, corrupt, disconnected Conservative Party … Labor vote; take Tory”.
Voting in Edinburgh has amplified a defining trend in Scottish politics, where political alliances are increasingly defined by a party’s position on Scotland’s constitutional future.
The Greens are pro-independence and, along with the proposed coalition agreement in Edinburgh, have supported a minority SNP administration in Glasgow, in addition to holding two ministerial posts in the Scottish government.
The SNP now manages the cities of Glasgow, where it narrowly retained power; Aberdeen, where he overthrew Labor; Dundee, where he won his only general majority; Perth, where he overthrew the Tories leading Perth and Kinross; and Inverness, where he leads the Highland Council in coalition with independents.
The SNP consolidated its position as the dominant party in Scotland on 5 May by winning 34% of the national vote share, its best performance on the council and 454 of the 1,227 seats on the Scottish Council, again its highest share to date.
In other areas where the SNP won a majority of seats but was blocked from power by pro-UK parties, Labor runs minority administrations in Stirling, South Lanarkshire, West Lothian, East Renfrewshire and Fife, often after offer non-political positions to other groups or independents.
Labor said they had stayed true to their promise to avoid coalition agreements; he added that he would work with the SNP and the Greens whenever possible, and did not assume that he would gain support for his policies from either the Lib Dems or the Conservatives.
Jackie Baillie, the Scottish Labor MP’s deputy leader, said: “Swinney’s sense of law is amazing. with the SNP or the Conservatives nowhere: that means we have to listen to all parties and councilors and reflect their concerns. ”
Sign up for First Edition, our free daily newsletter, every weekday morning at 7:00 BST
Scottish councilors are elected through the single transferable voting system of proportional representation, which makes it very unlikely that a party will get a full majority and is designed to promote work between parties.