Play the Brightcove video
Archie Battersbee’s family has won its appeal against a sentence that said the 12-year-old died.
Judges at the Court of Appeals said the case should be referred back to the High Court, where it will be heard by a judge who will decide whether it is in their best interest to end life support treatment.
Archie’s parents, Hollie Dance and Paul Battersbee, argued that the High Court judge, Judge Arbuthnot, erred in her recent ruling, which had concluded that doctors could stop treating her. legally.
Three appellate judges looked into the case at a Court of Appeal hearing in London on Wednesday and said there should be another High Court hearing.
In statements after the sentencing, Ms. Dance said the family was “delighted,” adding, “We wanted another audience and we have everything we wanted.”
Mr Battersbee said: “I couldn’t have gone better today.”
The new hearing is scheduled for July 11th.
Archie Battersbee’s mother, Hollie Dance, on the right, and family friend Ella Carter before the London High Court. Credit: PA
Archie suffered brain damage at his home on April 7 and was found unconscious with a ligament to his head. His mother, who found him, believes he may have taken part in an online challenge. He has not regained consciousness.
Lawyers representing Archie’s parents, Hollie Dance and Paul Battersbee, of Southend, Essex, began filing their case Wednesday morning.
Edward Devereux QC, who heads Archie’s parents ’legal team, told the judges,“ The case should be referred for consideration by a High Court judge who should consider whether it is in the best interest. of Archie continuing the vital treatment “.
The appellate judges Sir Geoffrey Vos, the Master of Roles; Sir Andrew McFarlane, President of the Family Division of the High Court and Highest Judge of the Family Courts of England and Wales; and Lady Justice King made their decision Wednesday afternoon.
Archie Battersbee was found unconscious at his home on April 7. Credit: Hollie Dance
Doctors treating Archie at Royal London Hospital in Whitechapel, east London, told Judge Arbuthnot how they thought she was “brain dead”, treatment should end and Archie should be disconnected from a fan.
Archie’s parents say her heart is still beating and they want her to continue treatment.
They had previously asked the judge for more time and said they would be “praying for miracles” for their son.
Following the High Court judge’s decision that Archie was already dead and that doctors could stop treating him legally, his family expressed their immediate intention to appeal.
In out-of-court statements, Ms. Dance vowed to fight the sentence and said the hospital was facing “the biggest battle in history.”
At a hearing to determine whether the family could appeal, Judge Arbuthnot heard the observations of the family’s lawyers and concluded that there was a “compelling reason” why the case should be referred to the Court. of Appeal.
Devereux said his evidence had not shown “beyond any reasonable doubt” that Archie was dead.
He said a decision had been made according to a balance of probabilities and argued that a decision of this “gravity” should have been made on a basis “beyond any reasonable doubt”.
Devereux argued that judges should apply a “standard of proof beyond any reasonable doubt,” not the balance of probabilities, when deciding whether to declare Archie dead.
Do you want a quick and expert briefing on the most important news? Listen to our latest podcasts to find out what you need to know