“The EPA told us that consulting the community would be a waste of time; in fact, they thought it made no sense to consult it because they knew what the community thought. But the lack of significant commitment caused social, psychological and financial stress. unnecessary to the affected communities, who felt abandoned in the dark. “
EPA Executive Director Lee Miezis spoke to the media after the ombudsman’s report was presented, acknowledging that the community was disappointed by the organization’s lack of significant commitment to the ombudsman. community.
He said the regulator had accepted that it could and should have done better at the time, but that there were proper processes now.
“I think there was a level of disconnect between the level of commitment required by law and the level of commitment that the community expected, and there was a gap,” Miezis said.
He said all regulators were under pressure from organizations and governments “who want a decision yesterday,” but that the EPA always evaluated applications thoroughly and rigorously.
Communities close to the three proposed sites in Ravenhall, Bacchus Marsh and Bulla expressed deep concern about contaminated soil, including fears that it could increase the risk of birth defects and terminal illnesses and contaminate waterways.
Loading
While the EPA followed the law and took a cautious approach to discarding the land, Glass found that residents were “left in the dark” because the authority was unable to engage significantly with the community.
EPA officials told the Ombudsman that they believed at the time that consulting the community would be a “waste of time” and that the discussions “could not be fruitful because of the community’s level of anger.”
Instead, the agency put “factual information” on its website, which Glass noted was heavily worded. This led to a breakdown in the EPA’s confidence and perception that it was putting its political and business interests ahead of its duties as an environmental health regulator.
“Lightning problems like the PFAS require more, not less, commitment. Lack of information and significant commitment increased fear and anxiety in the community,” Glass said in his report.
The Victoria Ombudsman was scathing about the EPA’s handling of the toxic gate spill of the West Gate Tunnel Project. Credit: Wayne Taylor
“We were told that the EPA” did not have the resources “to reverse the negative public perception of PFAS. However, it spent” hundreds of thousands of dollars “on legal advice.
Senior officials denied the investigation that there was any government interference, but Glass noted in his report that there was “little doubt that the EPA was under pressure to resolve the issue to recover the project.”
He noted that the dog helped the Department of Environment, Land, Water and Planning develop tailor-made regulations to pave the way for potential sites to receive toxic soil, which was eventually approved to be sent to a landfill in Bulla. north of Melbourne.
A former EPA executive director was bitten by the pressure he was putting on his agency to fix the toxic soil fiasco.
“It simply came to our notice then [the EPA]and I think it’s outrageous that we can get to a point where an advocate [John Holland Consortium] for the first time in Victorian history, at least, it says, “I want three places with full environmental and planning approvals,” because they could choose one or none of these places. I thought it was a scandalous situation driven by the contractual agreement, rather than an environmental agreement, “the executive director told investigators.
“I’ve been working on decision-making for a long time … and there’s always pressure for the EPA to hurry up or just fix it or make it go away, whether it’s from the minister’s office or the prosecutor’s.” or if this is from community groups. “
The EPA has accepted the four recommendations of the Ombudsman, which were:
- Review its focus on community involvement to address community concerns more directly;
- Consider improving your letter of inquiry;
- Ensure that decision-makers adhere to the human rights charter; i,
- Publish the unwritten 2021 environmental management plans submitted by the three landfill operators and the 2021 assessment reports of these plans.
Loading
The West Gate Tunnel was originally estimated to cost $ 5.5 billion, but the final contract for the highway was $ 6.7 billion. The state government in December confirmed that it would allocate an additional $ 2 billion to the project, as it looked like the price would rise beyond $ 10 billion.
The government considered stopping the project and finding a new builder after 13 months of grueling negotiations with Transurban, builders John Holland and CPB Contractors.
The tunnel linking the West Gate Freeway in Yarraville with CityLink in Docklands was due to open this year, but is years behind schedule due to the ground crisis.